A Night at Wildflower Ranch Inn; History, Hospitality, & Art

The History of the Best Places to Stay in Kentucky

I recently received an email from Rich and Carol, the current owners of Wildflower Ranch Inn, a bed-and-breakfast in Springfield, KY. I was offered an opportunity to stay the night and meet with the owners to discuss the home’s history. You know I accepted the offer! This past weekend, my daughter and I spent an evening in this beautiful 1871 Italianate-style farmhouse turned bed-and-breakfast.

It was an absolutely amazing evening! You know I’ll get to that, but before we do, I have to take you back in time. Interestingly enough, I’m taking you back to the McElroy family, a family I wrote a little bit about when we visited another B&B in Springfield this past May.

Wildflower Ranch Inn blends the historic with the modern. / Photos: Property of Kentucky Historic Travels (KHT)

So, let’s do a little bit of a revisit, and then we’ll travel down two different branches of the family tree to reach the McElroys who built this home. Yep, I said McElroys, as in more than one. Just wait. This one is complicated, but I’ll walk you through it, the best I can. So, come on, travel back in time with me to 1729, when the McElroy Clan arrived in Pennsylvania.

The McElroy Clan

This historical story begins with James (1705 -1772) and Sarah McCune (1708 – 1772) McElroy. It is believed that the spelling of their surname changed from McIlroy to McElroy when they left Scotland for Ireland or when they arrived in the British Colonies. The couple traveled from Belfast, Ireland, on the ship named “John of Dublin.” They came with many of their family and friends, including Reverend John and Mary Boyd Irvine, arriving in Philadelphia in 1729. (Pay attention to that Irvine name; you’re going to see it again in just a minute!)

In 1749, James McElroy purchased land along the Buffalo River, in what would become Prince Edward County, Virginia. He and his wife raised five sons: Archibald, John, Hugh, Samuel, and James Jr., and two daughters: Mary and Elizabeth.1 James McElroy Sr. and all five of his sons fought in both the French and Indian War and the American Revolution.2

The land purchased along Buffalo River was willed to James Jr. in 1772. James Jr. then sold the land in 1789 when he and two of his brothers, Hugh and Samuel, moved to Kentucky. Samuel and James settled in present-day Lebanon, Marion County, KY. Hugh settled in present-day Springfield, Washington County, KY. 3 (The McElroys likely received land in present-day Kentucky for their service in the Revolutionary War.)

An interesting little tidbit: Lebanon and Springfield are just 9 miles from one another, which is an 11-minute car ride today. In the 1700s, however, it would have taken approximately three hours to travel that distance by horse and buggy. I’d bet money they weren’t visiting their family in the other town very often.

Now, in order to arrive at Wildflower Ranch, we’re going to talk about two of those three brothers, Hugh and Samuel. Let’s take a look.

Hugh McElroy (1734 – 1794)

Hugh McElroy was born c. 1734 in Pennsylvania. He served in the Revolutionary War as either a private in Pennsylvania, a Lieutenant from Virginia, or possibly both.4

Around 1760, Hugh McElroy married Nancy Esther “Easter” Irvine5 in Campbell County, Colony of Virginia. Esther Irvine was the daughter of Rev. John Irvine. Remember, he came with James McElroy, Sr., in 1729? (Three of the five McElroy sons married daughters of Reverend John Irvine.)6

Hugh and Esther had ten children together: James, Margaret, Sarah, Mary, John, Hugh Jr., Samuel, Robert, William, and Elizabeth.

In the Spring of 1785, Hugh and his brother Samuel, along with Abraham Irvine, entered land on treasury warrants in Nelson County, KY, which is today’s Washington and Marion counties. The McElroy Clan – Samuel, Hugh, and James – moved their families to Kentucky no later than 1789.7

“In 1789, the three younger sons removed with their families to the extreme frontier in Kentucky. They and their numerous descendants have given name to the entire tribe of which James McElroy was the head, “The Kentucky McElroys.”

Find-a-Grave

Upon arrival, Hugh settled his wife and family on a farm “within the eastern limits of Springfield.”8 When Washington County was formed in 1792, the county Court established the first jail in a cabin belonging to Hugh McElroy. Several Court sessions were held at his home previous to the building of the Courthouse. It was Hugh who donated land for the first Courthouse to be built.9 Hugh was also one of the first trustees of Springfield when it was established in 1793. It was there that he built the first brick house between Danville and Bardstown, KY.10

Hugh died from an epidemic of smallpox that swept the county in 1794. His burial place is unknown.

Samuel McElroy Sr. (1740 – 1807)

Samuel was born c. 1745,11 likely in Pennsylvania, since the family did not purchase land in VA until 1749. However, some sources say he was born in Virginia. He married Mary Irvine, a daughter of Reverend John Irvine, in 1766 in Bedford Co., VA.

He served as a Virginia private in the Revolutionary War and was present at the surrender of Lord Cornwallis. He also furnished supplies to the Continental Army. 12

Samuel and Mary moved to Marion County, KY, in 1789, and settled within a “colony of Scotch-Irish Presbyterians.”13 The couple had 13 children together: Sarah, John, James, Hugh, Margaret, Abram (died young), William, Samuel, Mary, James, Abram, Elizabeth, and Nancy.14

Samuel died before May 4, 1807.15 According to Find-a-Grave, “Samuel [was] buried in Hardin’s Creek Presbyterian Church Cemetery, one of the oldest cemeteries in Lebanon with 250 to 300 graves. The gravestones were removed, and many were destroyed in 1958 when a playground was built. All that remains today are a few stones grouped together.” Many of the original graves are still there but are no longer marked by gravestones. That cemetery is located on Proctor Knott Avenue in Lebanon, Kentucky.

Some of those originally buried in the Hardin’s Creek Presbyterian Church Cemetery were moved to Ryder’s Cemetery. A DAR Patriot Marker for Samuel McElroy Sr. was approved and placed in the Ryder Cemetery “next to the large McElroy family gravestone of Samuel’s son, William Edwin, and his wife, Keturah,” in 2021.

2021 invitation to the grave marking for Samuel McElroy, Revolutionary War Patriot. / Image Credit: Find-a-Grave

Robert H. & Sarah Finley McElroy McElroy

We are now at the point where we are ready to introduce you to the builders of Wildflower Ranch, Mr. Robert H. McElroy and Mrs. Sarah “Finley” McElroy McElroy.16 I didn’t make a mistake; you are in fact seeing that name twice. Here’s where things get a bit complicated. So, I’m going to walk you through this family tree a few branches at a time. We’ll first look at Robert and then Sarah.

  • Robert H. McElroy (1831 – 1912)
    • Robert’s parents – Harvey McElroy(1805 – 1885) and Elizabeth Highlett Parrott (1802 – 1836)
    • Harvey’s parents / Robert F.’s paternal grandparents – Robert Abraham McElroy (1774 – 1834) and Disey Hundley McKinney
    • Robert Abraham’s parents / Robert H.’s paternal great-grandparents – Hugh McElroy (1734 – 1794) and Nancy Esther Irvine (1731 – 1800)
    • Hugh’s parents / Robert H.’s paternal great-great-grandparents – James and Sarah McCune McElroy
  • Sarah “Finley” McElroy (1840 – 1912)
    • Finley’s parents – Dr. Samuel Davis McElroy (1811 – 1844) and Mary Anna Tate (1812 – 1878)
    • Dr. Samuel Davis’s parents / Finley’s paternal grandparents – Samuel E. McElroy (1777 – 1847) and Marion Briggs
    • Samuel E.’s parents / Finley’s paternal great-grandparents – Samuel McElroy Sr. (1745 – 1806) and Mary Irvine (1749 – 1821)
    • Samuel’s parents / Finley’s paternal great-great-grandparents – James and Sarah McCune McElroy

As you can see, Robert H. and Sarah Finley shared the same set of great-great-grandparents, James and Sarah McCune, where we started our history. I didn’t get the cousin chart out, but basically, these two were distant-distant cousins. Robert H. was the great-grandson of Hugh, and Sarah was the great-granddaughter of Samuel.

Robert and Sarah married in 1862. They never had children and built their home in 1871. Little else is known about the timeline. Whether the land they built on was handed down or not, or who it might have been handed by, I don’t know. I also don’t know where they lived between 1862 and 1871, but they were likely living on this land. It’s also extremely likely that the Civil War had a massive effect on the couple and their ability to set up a home.

According to the summarized history I received from the current owners, John Hunt Morgan and his Raiders would have passed right by the McElroys ‘ farm.

John Hunt Morgan’s July 1862 raid in Kentucky hit Lebanon first, marching his men up the Old Lebanon Road, “passing by the McElroy farm, and into Springfield on the 5th.
The Battle of Perryville once again had Confederate troops coming north. That battle had so many wounded that homes and churches for miles around took in both [Union] and [Confederates]. If Robert and Finley had a prior home on the land, which is very likely, they probably had wounded at their home.”

Paperwork provided by current owners

Census Records Shed Some Light

We can only imagine what life was like during the Civil War, with battles taking place on your land or surrounding it. We can only imagine what it was like to see men from both sides marching by your home. Life would have been difficult, and building a home would likely have been impossible. With the help of U.S. Census records, we can get a small glimpse of what was happening with individuals and families.

For example, when looking at the 1860 Census, we learn that Robert H. was living with his father in Lebanon, then part of Marion County. Even though he was living with his father, Robert claimed that his real estate was valued at $1,600.00, and his personal estate was worth $4,000. So, it looks as if he owned land but did not yet live on it. He married just two years later in the midst of the Civil War, which continued until 1865.

By 1870, he and Finley were living in Springfield, Washington County, with real estate valued at $11,750 and a personal estate worth $11,000. On that U.S. Census Record, additional people are listed as living in the household with them: Fannie Crawford, 15 years old, listed as a Mulatto House Servant; Albert Kimball, an 11-year-old White Male listed as “At School”; George Kimball, a 22-year-old Mulatto Farm Laborer; and Harry (age 22) and Henry (age 19) Weathers, listed as Black Farm Laborers.

“Robert Finley is living on one of the best farms in the county 4 miles south of Springfield and is among the very best and most prosperous farmers in the county. He m. Finley McElroy, and has no children”

The Memoirs of Charles Rice McElroy via Papers provided by current owners

The McElroys Italianate-style farmhouse wasn’t built until 1871, so this 1870 Census sheds light on the fact that the couple was likely already on their land and possibly living in a home built prior to 1870, since they had a house servant living with them. (Here’s something to think about: Just 10 years before, Fannie, George, Harry, and Henry were likely to have been unnamed individuals on a Slave Census.)

In 1880, the McElroys’ home had been completed, and on the U.S. Census of that year, they were still living in Springfield, and Robert was listed as a Farmer. Their household included Alf and George Kimberlin, both listed as black farm laborers; Catherine Bosley, their 27-year-old black cook, and Mary Clarkson, their 16-year-old black house girl.

In 1900, the McElroys were listed as owning their farm, and Robert was still listed as a Farmer, even though he was then 69 years old. Additional individuals were not listed as living in their household, but I would believe they still had hired hands to help with the farming and housework.

Robert and Finley McElroy passed away in 1912, within just a few months of each other.

The McElroys’ Farmhouse

1960 Photo of the McElroys Farmhouse / Image Credit: The Wildflower Ranch Inn

The original Italianate-style farmhouse was a two-story frame construction home with wood plank siding and the common ell floor plan. In 2000, an addition was completed on the right side and back of the home. The right wing was integrated so well that, from the front-view exterior, it looks as if it has always been there. From the rear corner, the addition allowed for a unique tower-like architectural feature.

The view of the home as you come up the 1/2 mile-long driveway has you looking at the 2000 addition. / Photo property of KHT

In the 1871 section of the home, you’ll find gorgeous original poplar flooring, 12-foot ceilings on both floors, 8-foot doorways, original woodwork, ceiling medallions, doors, doorknobs, hinges, a floating staircase with original spindles and newel post, curved walls, and fireplaces in each room. On the first floor, in the original section, there is a beautiful entry, a parlour, a library (now used as the B&B’s breakfast room and gallery space), and a dining room.

Beautiful front doors and the Parlour Room / Photos property of KHT

On the second floor, in the original section, there are three bedrooms and a small sitting room (now used as the B&B’s massage room). The original porte-cochere, or carriage porch, has been transformed into a glass-enclosed porch that overlooks the in-ground pool, also added in 2000.

The Breakfast Gallery likely functioned as a Library / Photos propoerty of KHT

Leaving His Mark

Like painters that sign their name to their works, this home has a special mark on a special piece of artwork. The staircase is a pretty one, but the thing that really grabs your attention is the newel post. When you stop to admire it, you’ll realize it really is a work of art. Then, you’ll notice that the artwork is “signed” by the artist. Right there on the top of the post is the name J. H. Seay, and below it the word Builder. It’s clear Mr. Seay took pride in his work, and rightfully so!

J.H. Seay left his mark on the staircase. / Photos property of KHT

You know that I took the opportunity to dig a little into this builder who left his name on his artwork. So, I’ll take a moment to tell you what I learned about the man I believe to be this J. H. Seay.

John Hillery Seay (1835 – 1923)

John Hillery (J.H.) Seay was born in Lebanon, KY, in May 1835, to Edmond Booker Seay and Eleanor Ann Mattingly Seay.

This particular Seay Family (there were numerous Seays / Seas in the area) arrived in Washington County, Kentucky, in 1790. John Hillery’s grandfather, Jacob Seay Jr., had served in the American Revolution and likely came to claim land he would have received for his service. He settled “two miles west of Springfield on the Bardstown Road.” He was successful in his new home and became a prominent citizen, serving as Mayor for “15 to 20 years” and “two years [as] high Sheriff”17 in Washington County. According to the family sketch written in 1906, Jacob bought land and “built good homes.”

Maybe it was because of his grandfather’s construction skills that John Hillery Seay became a carpenter. It was again through U.S. Federal Census records that I gained the most information. I learned John Hillery Seay was a carpenter, was born in Lebanon, KY, first married Mary Jane Kidwell in 1855, moved to Indiana, where he served in the Civil War in Company D, 24th Indiana Volunteer Infantry, moved back to Springfield, Kentucky, in 1870 when his first wife died, married Nancy E. Lee in LaRue County, KY, on November 15, 1874, and later moved to Chattanooga, Tennessee, where he died in 1923.

J. H. Seay’s Obituary and Headstone / Image Credit: Find-a-Grave

John and Nancy “Nannie” had several children together, but I paid close attention to Edmund “Eddie” Seay, who became a cabinet maker, and John R. Seay, who became a carpenter.

With all of this information, I feel that this John Hillery Seay I just told you about is VERY likely THE J. H. Seay who built this staircase. What do you think? Have I built a strong case about the builder of this staircase?

The Staircase Built by J. H. Seay in 1871 / Photos property of KHT

Our Visit

I hope you’ve enjoyed the history of the home and its builders. It’s now time to take a look at it today.

My daughter and I pulled up the drive just as dark settled in over the 7-acre property. I hated to miss sunset, but with 5:30 PM sunsets this time of year, it’s really hard to catch them. We parked the car and began unloading our bags. We were greeted by Rich, who ushered us through the front door and into the historic section of the home.

After introductions, we were shown to the Blackberry Blossom Suite, the room we would get to enjoy for the night. Rich explained that the suite was the “new” section of the home. He opened the doors and led us into the space. I’m fairly certain my daughter and I both expressed a “WOW!” at the same time.

The Blackberry Blossom Suite wasn’t just a room; it was a wing – an 1,100-square-foot space – that made our jaws drop.

The Blackberry Blossom Suite was “once the Owner’s Quarters,” added to the home in 2000. / Photos property of KHT

Rich bid us farewell for a moment to let us settle in. We agreed to meet in the parlour a few minutes later to discuss the history of the home. My daughter and I took a few minutes to unpack our things and explore the room. My daughter commented on the impressive size. She said the shower was the size of her dorm room, and I said the suite was the size of my first house! 🤣

Wildflower Ranch’s website says the private suite “will envelop you with five-star luxury,” offering “tranquility and quiet.” They’re not lying! This space was more than we could have ever dreamed of! After picking our jaws up off the floor, we made our way to the parlour to meet up with Rich and Carol.

In the parlour, we were introduced to Carol, who had been finishing up a special treat for us when we arrived. On the table sat a beautiful tea set, with freshly brewed tea and a lovely plate of Earl Grey scones with lemon frosting. (I do wish I had taken a picture!) We settled on the comfy sofa and began talking about our own personal stories while enjoying the special treats. (Oh my goodness! The tea and scones were absolutely delectable! I don’t use that word lightly, by the way. I’d eat an entire plate of those scones daily if I could.) Through our conversation, we learned that Rich and Carol are transplants. Rich is originally from California, and Carol is originally from Ohio but made her way to California, where the two met. Carol’s maternal grandparents were from the Berea, KY, area, so she does have Kentucky roots. It was those roots that ultimately brought Rich and Carol to Kentucky in 2018. That’s when they purchased the McElroy Farmhouse property, named it Wildflower Ranch Inn, and opened it as a bed-and-breakfast.

Why name it Wildflower Ranch? Well, Wildflower is a nod to their dedication to promoting pollinators. Twelve orchard trees have been planted already, along with 125 Dutch tulip bulbs, and there are plans for more native trees, flowers, and grasses. Ranch is a nod to their own “out west” history. It’s a pretty cool name, don’t you think?

Both Rich and Carol are artists by trade, so they wanted to blend art with the history. Their art is hung beautifully throughout the home. They also hold art classes and workshops in the pool house turned art studio, perfectly named The Art Distillery.

Just a few of the art pieces found throughout the home. / Photos: property of KHT, artwork property of Rich and Carol of Wildflower Ranch Inn

After our conversation was complete, it was finally time for a tour of the home! We had the opportunity to see every room but one, as it was occupied for the night. We finished our tour in the custom kitchen that was also part of the 2000 addition, added to the back of the home. Now, the kitchen is not a typical part of the experience, but it was awesome to see. The kitchen was also the size of my first home!

Wildflower Ranch Interior Photos / All property of KHT

We wrapped up our time with Rich and Carol for the evening – we talked for 2 hours – and headed back to our suite. My daughter and I agreed we would take turns enjoying the super-sized shower/sauna and then curl up in the king-sized bed. (Yep, the shower was also a sauna! Just hit the button and give it about 10 minutes, and the room was filled with steam so thick you could hardly see. The shower had multiple sprays: one from the ceiling, one from the typical shower spot, and either 4 or 5 body sprays. It was fantastic! I highly recommend!) We finished the evening curled up in a very comfy bed, reading books, watching a movie, and coloring. Yes, we brought coloring books and crayons (we both still love to color), a laptop with a DVD player, and the books we’re currently reading. Needless to say, we don’t travel light! 🤣

The next morning, I was up bright and early because I wanted to get pictures of the home before breakfast. I left my daughter to sleep in for a bit, and I explored the home inside and out, in the beautiful sunshine.

Exterior Photos of Wildflower Ranch Inn / Photos property of KHT

Finally, it was time for breakfast, so I woke my daughter, and we packed up our things from the night before. We made it to the breakfast table at 9 AM, greeted by Rich and Carol, who offered us coffee or tea and presented us with a gorgeous plate of scratch-made quiche, fried apples, and Kentucky sausage. The plate itself was like a piece of art! And the taste? Delicious!

The breakfast presentation was a work of art. / Photos property of KHT

After breakfast, it was time to head back to the real world. We hated to do it; it’s really rude to eat and run, but my daughter had to get to work. We loaded our bags and returned to say goodbye to our new friends. We couldn’t leave without a property Kentucky hug for the road. Before loading up and pulling out of the driveway, we continued our tradition of grabbing a selfie in front of the home.

Reflection

Oh my! Where do I start? First, we were floored to be offered the gorgeous Blackberry Blossom Suite; it was way more than we could ever have asked for, and we are forever grateful to Rich and Carol for the experience.

There are so many things that I love about this home, its history, and our experience. First, I love that the history of this home is so different from any other we’ve visited. The McElroys weren’t doctors, lawyers, senators, or governors. They were farmers. Successful farmers, but just average Kentucky farmers out there doing their best to make a living. The fact that we still have the home of an average Kentuckian is pretty cool.

I love that this home is post-Civil War. It’s an architectural style that we typically don’t see or experience. That, too, is really cool.

I love that the modern conveniences of bathrooms and a kitchen were placed in the “new” addition. The 1871 section is pretty much exactly as it was when it was built. Now, I will add that one bedroom upstairs does have a bathroom added in the corner. The other two upstairs bedrooms do not have in-room bathrooms. There is a hall bath that the two rooms share, and the bathroom is in the addition just a few steps from the bedrooms.

I love that the addition was done so well; you can’t tell it’s an addition from the outside. I love that the new hallways have flooring that matches the original poplar floors so well; you can’t tell they are new. I love that this home feels historic and fresh at the same time. It truly is a perfect blend of both worlds.

I love that Rich and Carol both love to cook. I love that they use organic, local, fresh ingredients and make everything from scratch. I love that they serve Danville’s Elmwood Teas. I love that they bring their love of art, not only to the home, but to the plate.

As usual, I could go on and on. This truly was a wonderful experience, and I am so thankful Rich and Carol invited us out to experience their corner of the world in one of Kentucky’s historic treasures.

If you have the chance to visit and stay the night, I highly recommend doing so. The accommodations are comfy, the hospitality is Southern, and breakfast is top-notch. (One thing to know before you go: you will not find a television in your room. Make sure to pack a book, a game, or be like us and bring your coloring book and crayons!)

If you are not able to stay, be on the lookout for special events that are held throughout the year, such as farm-to-table dinners and tea times. That will allow you to see this Italianate farmhouse and support a small business at the same time!

So, go ahead and book a stay. I promise you’ll love it! You never know; you just might find me there this summer sitting by the pool!

Until next time…


Sources:

  1. Prince Edward Co., VA. Wills, 1754-1776, 1991 by T.L.C. Genealogy ↩︎
  2. McElroy family newsletter – no.1 (March 1976) via FamilySearch.org ↩︎
  3. McElroy Newsletters, Vol. 1 & 2, 1976-1977. Located in the S.A. Library, Mar. 1993, via Geni.com ↩︎
  4. McElroy family newsletter – no.1 (March 1976) via FamilySearch.org ↩︎
  5. Washington County, Kentucky Will Book A, page 27 ↩︎
  6. McElroy family newsletter – no.1 (March 1976) via FamilySearch.org ↩︎
  7. McElroy, Reverend John, M. D.D., “The Scotch-Irish McElroys in America A.D. 1717 – A.D. 1900,” Fort Orajjgb Press, Brandow Printing Co., Albany, NY, 1901 via Internet Archive ↩︎
  8. McElroy Newsletters, Vol. 1 & 2, 1976-1977. Located in the S.A. Library, Mar. 1993, via Geni.com ↩︎
  9. Paperwork from current owners ↩︎
  10. Pioneer History of Washington County, Kentucky by Orval W. Baylor. ↩︎
  11. Samuel McElroy, DAR Patriot Record ↩︎
  12. Washington County, Kentucky Bicentennial History 1792 – 1992, Turner Publishing Company, Paducah, KY, 1991 ↩︎
  13. Washington County, Kentucky Bicentennial History 1792 – 1992, Turner Publishing Company, Paducah, KY, 1991 ↩︎
  14. McElroy family newsletter – no.1 (March 1976) via FamilySearch.org ↩︎
  15. Samuel McElroy, DAR Patriot Record ↩︎
  16. 1900 U.S. Federal Census via FamilySearch.org ↩︎
  17. A brief sketch of the Seay Family written by James A. Seay in 1906, via Kentucky Kindred Genealogy ↩︎

Leave a Reply